Insights
Give your brand a backbone
The future belongs to brands with the courage to question, the will to create and the wisdom to care, says Terry van Rhyn.
In Greek mythology, Prometheus stole fire from the gods and gave it to humanity. It was a rather audacious act, particularly as Zeus wasn’t known for his forgiving nature. But fire represented more than warmth. It symbolised knowledge, independence, innovation and the ability to shape our own destiny.
Thousands of years later, I wonder whether the marketing industry could benefit from a little Promethean thinking. Somewhere along the way, many brands appear to have surrendered their fire.
They’ve become remarkably good at following conventions, embracing best practice, studying competitors and producing increasingly sophisticated variations of precisely the same thing. Perhaps it’s time to question what brands are supposed to achieve.
The problem with fitting in
Much of modern marketing is built around conformity disguised as strategy. Businesses study their competitors, identify category conventions, commission research and develop propositions designed to appeal to the broadest possible audience.
The result is often a carefully considered exercise in being unremarkable. Banks promise trust. Insurance companies offer peace of mind. Technology businesses empower innovation. Almost everyone is passionate about excellence. It’s difficult to differentiate yourself when you’re all reading from the same script.
Promethean philosophy offers a different perspective. At its heart is the belief that progress comes through independent thought, courage, creativity and the willingness to challenge established assumptions.
Applied to branding, it suggests something rather important: a brand should not simply reflect the market in which it operates – it should have the ambition to improve it.
That doesn’t require revolutionary products or grandiose promises to change the world. Sometimes it simply means finding a better way to serve customers. But it begins with the courage to think independently.
Vision is not a statement on the boardroom wall
Most businesses have a vision statement. Unfortunately, many are written by committees, approved by boards and promptly forgotten by everyone else. They sound impressive but rarely influence what happens on a Tuesday morning. A genuine vision should answer three fundamental questions.
- What do we believe?
- Why does it matter?
- And what are we prepared to do differently because of it?
The first establishes conviction. The second establishes purpose. The third establishes accountability. Without that final question, a vision is little more than corporate decoration.
A useful vision should also describe a future the organisation wants to help create, rather than simply declaring its ambition to become the market leader. Being number one is an aspiration for the business. Making something meaningfully better is a proposition for the world beyond it. There’s an important difference.
Culture is where the brand becomes real
A brand’s identity and, crucially, its culture are not created exclusively by its marketing department. It’s created by the everyday decisions and behaviour of the people who represent it: how they treat customers, respond to mistakes, if they are encouraged to challenge established thinking, and honour promises when doing so becomes inconvenient. In short, do the organisation’s stated values survive contact with commercial reality?
This is where Promethean thinking becomes particularly relevant. An organisation that celebrates innovation in its advertising but punishes employees for questioning management has a credibility problem. A business that promotes integrity but rewards questionable sales practices has a cultural problem. And a company that claims to care about customers while measuring success exclusively through short-term revenue has a strategic problem.
Culture isn’t what a business says it believes. It’s what its people understand they’re expected to do. Where intellectual curiosity is encouraged, and assumptions challenged; where people have the freedom and resources to improve things; and where there is recognition that commercial success carries responsibilities. Expectations are established for behaviour – and it is behaviour that customers experience.
They encounter the receptionist, the website, the delivery driver, the packaging, the product and the person handling their complaint. Every interaction provides evidence of what the business genuinely believes. Over time, these experiences create expectations. Expectations influence trust. Trust influences preference and preference can influence purchasing decisions, loyalty and recommendation.
This is the relationship between internal culture and external brand reputation. Not a mysterious emotional connection manufactured by advertising, but a cumulative judgement formed through experience.
Of course, consumers are not always rational. Price, convenience, habit, social influence and availability all affect purchasing behaviour. A compelling culture doesn’t eliminate those considerations, but it can create a meaningful advantage when customers have choices.
Leadership must give away the fire
Perhaps the most powerful aspect of the Prometheus story is that he didn’t keep the fire for himself. He gave humanity the means to advance. There’s a valuable lesson for business leaders.
Leadership shouldn’t be about concentrating knowledge, authority and decision-making at the top. It should be about developing the capabilities of others. People are more likely to contribute original thinking when they have the knowledge, confidence and permission to do so. That requires trust, clear expectations and accountability. It also requires leaders who are sufficiently secure to be challenged.
A culture of independent thought doesn’t mean everyone does whatever they please. It means people understand the organisation’s purpose and have the freedom to exercise judgement within it. The strongest brands aren’t necessarily those with the most charismatic leaders. They’re the ones whose values remain evident when the leader isn’t in the room.
The future belongs to those who think
We live in an age when technology can generate content, analyse consumer behaviour, automate communication and replicate almost any established creative convention.
Whilst artificial intelligence has made producing marketing material easier than ever, it has also made producing more of the same easier than ever. The competitive advantage will increasingly lie not simply in the ability to produce, but in the judgement to decide what’s worth producing.
Original thinking, genuine conviction, a distinctive culture and the discipline to translate beliefs into behaviour – these are qualities that cannot be downloaded as a brand template. They have to be developed, demonstrated and defended.
Prometheus gave humanity fire because he believed in its potential. Perhaps businesses should approach their people and customers with similar ambition. Not simply asking how to sell them more, but how to create something genuinely worth choosing.
Because, ultimately, a brand is not what an organisation claims it to be. It’s the reputation earned through what it consistently does.